The Smithy
If you're in the mood for delicious food and a welcoming atmosphere, The Smithy is the place to be! Nestled at 171 Main St in Monroe, CT, this cozy restaurant offers a dining experience that’s perfect for both casual meals and special gatherings. Whether you’re grabbing a bite with friends, enjoying a family dinner, or celebrating with a group, The Smithy has something for everyone.
One of the standout features of The Smithy is its diverse menu, which boasts an array of mouthwatering dishes. If you’re a seafood lover, don’t miss the Brazilian Lobster Tails—cooked to perfection and bursting with flavor. For something hearty, the Filet Mignon is an absolute must-try, offering tender, juicy cuts that melt in your mouth. If you’re in the mood for something with a bit of a kick, the Lamb Chops bring rich, bold flavors that will leave you coming back for more. And let’s not forget the Clam Chowder—it’s creamy, comforting, and perfect for those cold evenings. The Rice Pilaf complements any dish with its savory, well-seasoned flavor, making it the perfect side to round off your meal.
The Smithy’s ambiance is laid-back and casual, making it an ideal spot for groups or families with kids. The moderate noise level creates a lively but not overwhelming atmosphere, so you can enjoy a great conversation while savoring your food. If you love dining outdoors, you’ll be happy to know that they offer outdoor seating, letting you enjoy a fresh breeze while you indulge in your meal.
The vibe here is relaxed yet vibrant, offering a welcoming space where you can unwind and enjoy fantastic food in a friendly, comfortable environment. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, The Smithy is definitely worth a visit for anyone looking for a memorable dining experience.
Reviews
We had such a nice time visiting The Smithy last night. The host was very friendly and gave us a seat very close to the fire place which was lovely. The service was very polite and informative, as it was our first time there. The salad bar was very fresh with a few different choices. The cracker station with cheese block was a fun and different option rather than your usual bread basket. I decided to go with the filet mignon and baked potato and my fiancé ordered the striploin and lobster tail. We both enjoyed our meals very much. The ambiance was cozy and the service was warm and welcoming. We wish we lived nearby, we would definitely come often. We will definitely visit the next time we are in town. Thank you for such a nice evening!
Love everything about the smithy ! We have been coming here since the day the opened years ago. Love the menu lots of things to pick from steak is the best and the lobster tail is the bomb. The only thing I was not crazy about was the prime rib .
I'm leaving this at four stars - for the benefit of the doubt - and another return will be due. I've been here plenty of times, always returned with the same expectations, great food, amazing service, and intimate. However returning after 6-8 years later, renovations, new owners - those expectations did not hold. I still adore the place, love the cheese board, however I do miss two options. And the salad bar is a must grab. There's more types of dressing than there are toppings but are sufficient. They added to their menu, upgrading from 3-5 options, I find the quality lacking. Too much for one cook, overwhelmed with many plated options and battling the crowd. And the food showed for that. Porterhouse ordered medium rare - arrived a dry medium rare which upgrades it to an immediate well done. Ribeyes were given justice which is why I saved this post at four stars. Service was impeccable, great explanations, servicing multiple tables, and attentive. The place has been updated and I'm glad they kept the fireplace, although the red walls are gone the fireplace keeps it cozy.
This place is great. Best steak place I have been to outside of the brand name, high end steakhouses. Service was quiet and very attentive. I ordered the 18" cowboy steak and it was tasty and cooked to perfection. My wife had a different cut and it was also excellent. They have a salad bar that comes with dinner and a cheese tray that you can serve yourself
Went for the first time and enjoyed our visit. Cozy fireplace as you enter. Food was good, loved the little cheese and cracker snack. Only damper was a large noisy party, that also likely stressed out our waiter. He cut us off a number of times as we were a little undecided and just wanted to chat a little but he made us feel like we were wasting his time and he had to get food out. We'll be back again to give it another try and hopeful it was just an off night.